Located in the heart of Oneonta, New York, at 285-1 Main St, Sal's Original Pizzeria stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of classic, hand-crafted pizza. For those who appreciate the artistry of a well-made pie, this local establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere that bridges the gap between a quick neighborhood bite and a comfortable place to gather with friends and family. The essence of the pizzeria is rooted in the simple philosophy of using quality ingredients to create familiar, comforting flavors that resonate with both long-time residents and visitors passing through the scenic landscapes of upstate New York.
Stepping into Sal's Original Pizzeria, guests are immediately greeted by the inviting aroma of dough rising and savory sauces simmering. It is the kind of place where the craft of pizza making is taken seriously, yet the environment remains entirely unpretentious. Whether you are looking for a casual lunch break during a busy workday or a relaxed dinner to unwind after exploring the local area, the pizzeria provides a consistent experience that prioritizes the integrity of the food. The commitment to maintaining a standard of excellence has allowed the shop to become a recognizable fixture within the Oneonta community, serving as a reliable destination for those seeking a genuine slice of pizza culture.
What Makes Sal's Original Pizzeria Stand Out
Authentic Preparation Methods: The kitchen focuses on traditional techniques that emphasize the importance of crust texture and flavor balance, ensuring that every pie reflects a dedication to the craft of authentic pizza making.
Community-Centric Atmosphere: Situated conveniently on Main Street, the restaurant serves as a central hub for locals, fostering a friendly environment that welcomes everyone from students to families and local professionals.
Consistent Quality and Care: By prioritizing fresh ingredients and careful preparation, the team at Sal's ensures that each order meets a high standard of quality, providing a reliable dining experience for all patrons.
Accessible Location: Being located in the heart of Oneonta makes it an ideal stop for those navigating the downtown area, offering easy access for both dine-in customers and those looking for a convenient meal to go.
The appeal of a pizzeria like Sal's often lies in its ability to remain grounded in its roots while serving a diverse and ever-changing community. In an era where dining trends shift rapidly, there is something inherently satisfying about a business that focuses on doing one thing exceptionally well. The attention to detail in the kitchen, combined with a genuine desire to provide a pleasant experience for every guest, creates a sense of belonging that is hard to replicate. It is this dedication to the fundamentals of hospitality and culinary consistency that keeps the doors open and the ovens running day after day.
Ultimately, Sal's Original Pizzeria of Oneonta represents more than just a place to eat; it is a part of the local fabric that contributes to the unique character of the town. By maintaining a focus on quality and community, the establishment continues to serve as a go-to spot for anyone craving a classic, satisfying meal. Whether you are a local resident who has been visiting for years or a newcomer eager to sample the local flavors, the team at Sal's is ready to provide a warm welcome and a slice of tradition that feels right at home in the heart of Oneonta.
As you plan your next visit to the area, consider stopping by 285-1 Main St to experience the straightforward, honest approach to pizza that has defined this location. It is a reminder that sometimes the best dining experiences are the ones that keep things simple, focus on the quality of the ingredients, and treat every customer like a neighbor. We invite you to discover why so many people in Oneonta consider this pizzeria a staple of their weekly routine and a reliable choice for a great meal.
Amenities and More
Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Atmosphere
Casual
Quiet
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free street parking
Menus
Breakfast Biscuits
Sausage Egg & Cheese$5.00
Bacon Egg & Cheese$5.00
Ham Egg & Cheese$5.00
Sides Large $5 Small $3
Fries
Green Beans
Butter Beans
Fried Okra
Potato Salad
Pasta Salad
Kernel Corn
Wild Rice
Cole Slaw
Baked Beans
Mashed Potatoes
mac n' chz
Pizza
Regular Slice$3.25
Sicilian Slice$4.50
Gluten-Free$14.00
Cheese$15.00
White$16.00
Grandma$24.00
Sicilian$21.00
Sheet Pizza$25.00
Honey Barbeque Pizza$19.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza$19.00
Hawaiian$19.00
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch$19.00
Sal's Supreme$25.00
Meat Lovers$23.00
Veggie Supreme$22.00
Caprese$22.00
Charcuterie Roni/Hot Honey$25.00
Margherita$18.00
Baked Ziti$23.00
Specialties
Calzone$14.00
Choice of each additional item in calzone$2.00
Chicken Rolls$15.00
Stromboli$17.00
Roni Stromboli$15.00
Small Bites
Garlic Knots$0.50
Pepperoni Twist$1.00
Garlic Bread$3.00
Garlic Bread with Cheese$4.50
French Fries$7.00
Cheesy Fries$8.50
Onion Rings$7.50
Mozzarella Sticks$9.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries$14.00
Chicken Wings (dozen)$15.00
Hot Subs
Meatball Parm, Eggplant, Parm, Chicken Parm$16.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onions$16.00
Philly Cheese Steak$16.00
Chicken Cutlet$16.00
Cold Subs
Turkey Breast$14.00
Ham, Cheese$14.00
Italian Mix$16.00
Chicken Cutlet$16.00
Salads
Tossed Salad$8.00
Antipasto Salad$14.00
Caesar Salad$12.00
Caesar Salad with Chicken$14.00
Grilled, Crispy, or Buffalo Chicken Salad$14.00
Entrées
Spaghetti or Penne with Tomato Sauce or Garlic & Olive Oil$12.00
Spaghetti or Penne with Meatball or Sausage$17.00
Spaghetti or Penne with Alfredo$18.00
Spaghetti or Penne with Alfredo & Veggies$21.00
Spaghetti or Penne with Alfredo & Chicken$22.00
Spaghetti or Penne with Alfredo, Chicken, & Veggies$25.00
Manicotti$22.00
Cheese Ravioli$22.00
Smothered Meatballs$22.00
Baked Ziti$22.00
Regular Lasagna$22.00
Eggplant Parmigiana$22.00
Chicken Parmigiana$23.00
Eggplant Rollatini$25.00
Side of meatballs or sausage$6.00
Desserts
Cannolis$5.00
Homemade Chocolate Mousse$7.00
Zeppolis$8.00
Funnel Fries$6.00
add Cannoli Cream$2.00
Photos
Reviews Sal's Original Pizzeria Of Oneonta
Ann Jordan
30-05-2026
Ecstatic that Oneonta has the original Sal's back again. Favorite pizza for our whole family! Welcome back, so happy for your return!
Austin Brown
30-05-2026
10/10 best pizza in Oneonta. So glad the original owners are back!
Lea Moscatello
30-05-2026
Amazing pizza made by the best around!! Anytime you walk in you’ll feel like family!!
Britney Fraser
30-05-2026
Sal's ORIGINAL pizzeria is hands down the BEST PIZZA IN ONEONTA!!!!!! The owners are absolutely amazing
Crystal S (slay3r cryst9l)
30-05-2026
Glad to have original Sal's back. Great food, people, and all around great atmosphere!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Tyler Clark
30-05-2026
Love sals always been a good to place
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Scott Bonderoff
30-05-2026
Best pizza! Stopped after the Train concert and had an absolutely perfect slice of pepperoni pizza.
zach
30-05-2026
Smelled good. Friendly staff. Good pizza.
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
No wait
Anne Smart
30-05-2026
Forever favorite pizzeria! 🍕 So good to see the family back at it! Sal’s is a slice of home!❤️ …
Bryan Tarbell
30-05-2026
We are back and it is so good. I bought ten random slices and they tossed in some "small slices" for free. The pros are back!
Warduke
30-05-2026
Great place to get food and they’re not closed when all the other people are!!!!! love the pizza extra crispy
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Ghosty
30-05-2026
Small ass calzone got told on the phone it feeds 2 people that’s bullshit 16$ go to mollys in the mall feed definitely 2 people and it’s only 10$ 12 with one topping. Honestly won’t be back unfortunately More
M Duke
30-05-2026
Even though Sal's reopened....something about the sauce is just blahh...I was disappointed because I thought it would be great again.
Debbie rathbun
30-05-2026
Ordered a stromboli hardly any meat nothing but bread tasteless never again garbage
linda galloway
30-05-2026
So friendly and pizza was delicious! Wonderful family run restaurant! Thanks for such a welcoming environment! More
Max “MaxDuderino” Duderino
30-05-2026
This is a great spot to get a slice of New York style pizza, the only reason that they didn't get a Solid 5 stars is because the sauce is just a little sweet for my taste, really it would be 4 1/2 if I had the option. (Also I'm not saying … More
Tommy Laurel
30-05-2026
Service was good restaurant is clean . But although pizza was perfectly thin had nice undercarriage minimal flop and a good crunch The very sweet taste and the texture of the cheese, which seems to have a mix of American in it, ruined the whole thing for me. More
Robert Holmes
30-05-2026
Great people, great food. I love ordering here. Sheet pizza is nice and not to expensive either
Order…
More
Sarah Franchi
30-05-2026
LOVE LOVE LOVE the original Sals in oneonta. Went there the other day and they had one of my favorite pizza slices (ziti pizza) available.
To say it was a good day was an understatement!
Plus the garlic knots are out of this world!
Anthony Leonardo
30-05-2026
It always feels great walking into Sal's and seeing Joe and John. They always remember who you are even if you haven't been by in a while. The food is always 10 out of 10. I'm so glad they're back. More
Stephanie Willsey
30-05-2026
Oh, to have Sal’s back! I had to get a large cheese and wings before I left town and it did not disappoint! There is no better pizza in the area….honestly nothing even compares. Pizza was perfect as it always was, wings were spicy and … More
Kaleigh Herman
30-05-2026
I’ve loved this pizza my entire life. While they were gone, i really didn’t even eat pizza much because nothing would even come close. I’m SO happy they’re back! Everything is so delicious, and tastes just like it always did. Best in the area and beyond! 🫶🏻 … More
Chelsea Leonardo
30-05-2026
The best of the best pizza of Oneonta. Always great service and family atmosphere. Prices are also very great for the value. So happy to have the original back. More
Dennis Daskalakis
30-05-2026
This is the best pizza in Oneonta. They have a classic rock station playing on Sirius XM. They also have a lunch special two slices for $5. More
John Abrams
30-05-2026
Excellent pizza, from the crust up. Great people and family that run the shop! So glad the real Sal's is back
Derrick Balloqui-Smith
30-05-2026
Sals own calzone has absolutely ruined any other calzone anywhere for me. It is so spot on and perfect that anywhere else leaves my hopes dashed. Was my first calzone in 1984 and defined expectation since. Nobody else can compare! So glad you guys are back and I’m coming on a pilgrimage! More
Jonathan Fanduiz
30-05-2026
Sal’s was great! My company was throwing a pizza party for one of our partner stores, and Sal’s was able to have 13 pies ready to go in one hour after opening! Price was great and most importantly the pizza was too. Even helped me carry it to the car. Thanks! More
Lenny Sutliff
30-05-2026
One of the best pizza places in town. Used to order from here all the time until I moved out of the area. Staff is very friendly and helpful food is amazing. Very friendly atmosphere. And now as a doordash driver when coming in to pick up an order food is ready when the app says it will be available. Very fast and efficient service More
Sam Smith
30-05-2026
Always has been always will be the best. Treated my 65 year old neighbor to a meat lovers slice and he said "this is the best pizza I've had in my whole life" he had to know where I got it from. Chicken honey mustard slice pictured below. Also can't beat the prices.
Mike Scott
30-05-2026
Got the margherita pizza on a cold Veteran's Day. Amazing pie, great ingredients, and hot as all heck. Might be the best thin crust I've ever had, and the addition of crushed garlic to the simple stewed tomato/fresh mozz/fresh basil and olive oil put it over the top! More
Reviews Sal's Original Pizzeria Of Oneonta